| Winner | Prize | Donor |
| emptyscull2 | PCGS MS67 Ike | Laz |
| dlsharp | 16X Loupe |  |
| kdmay48 | 2004 Silver Eagle | nomorehoneydos |
| rwilharm | variety coin lot | Laz |
| grasshopper04943 | 1978-P certified Ike | Laz |
| Astronaut _Coin_Collector | 10 gram beam scale | loucoins |
| andrewsnovell | 2003 B/S Dime & defaced die | Fred Weinberg |
| yobro54 | coin supplies | airtiteguy |
| tymothybates | Ancient Roman error book | Fred Weinberg |
| Smitty | Error Coin Encyclopedia | Fred Weinberg |
| Dee | 16X Loupe | |
| thegasman821 | Looking at Lincoln Cent's Book by C.Daughtrey | rwilharm |
| snakebro | Silver Maple Leaf | Laz |
| dbldeye | dbl clip Quarter | Fred Weinberg |
| loucoins | 2003 Siver Eagle | td51730 |
| barberman | framed Early Mint photograph | Fred Weinberg |
| rockyphila | Rare Gold VHS | Fred Weinberg |
| Goose | 16X Loupe | |
| cwperry | Silver Maple Leaf | Laz |
| ukgeezer61 | Bahamas/N.Z. mule | swren |
| mickkis010 | 16X Loupe | |
| coinnut4 | BU Roll 1967 Kennedy 50c | andysnovell |
| Jake_Tuba | 16X Loupe | |
| preacherbear | 1967 Canadian Mint set | Coin Nut |
| racegirl032 | mystery prize | jtwax |
| chuckylucky4 | Panama Silver Balboa coin | Laz |
| nomorehoneydos | Cherry Picker's Guide & die | Fred Weinberg |
| td51730 | Conn. State 25c error | Astronaut_Coin_Collector |
| chuck-1956 | 1971-D ms64 Ike | Laz |
| kakaratt | 1c & 5c errors | Fred Weinberg |
| jnd1955 | 2003 Proof Set | Coin Nut |
| JimB | BU New Zealand Crown | Laz |
| marko72760 | 1982-D & S Wash comm. halves | Dee |
| poorboycoins | 1971-P MS64 Ike | Laz |
| my_errors | BU Walker 50c | jnd1955 |
| wxrbuff2 | 2001 P&D Kennedy 50c | |
| lalasd4 | Cent & Dime errors | Fred Weinberg |
| starbque | 16X Loupe | |
| desktoplinux | 2 Mexican Libertads | Coin Nut |
| Dinosaur | certified Ike Dollar | Laz |
| rottnrog | $50. gift Certificate | Stanton Books |
 luvthree | 1990 Certifed Ike Proof 69 | Laz |
| walkermtmanus | 5 rolls unsearched Wheaties | Surok98 |
| blt_mb | B/S Dime & defaced die | Fred Weinberg |
